-
Hello!
Just a quick clarification:
in http://rules.wfdf.org/discussions/interpretations/111-scoring-from-a-pull#499 you say that it is possible to score a callahan on a pull, while in http://rules.wfdf.org/discussions/interpretations/133-pull-lands-in-the-endzone-of-the-pulling-team#581 you say it is not, as the disc cannot be defended.
The latter one is more recent: can I share it as the correct interpretation?
Sorry for being so punctilious! 😳
7.7. No player on the defensive team may touch the disc after a pull until a member of the offensive team contacts the disc or the disc contacts the ground.
According to 7.7. it’s not possible to score a Callahan on a pull.
If an offensive player touches the disc (failing to catch it) and a defender catches it before touching the ground I guess that could be valid goal (Callahan).
I am saying the same thing in both posts:
1. By the rules it is a score.
2. Philosophically, it should not be a score. The rules should potentially be rewritten here.About the other comment:
we are talking about the receiving team catching the score on a really really really bad pull from the other team.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.